How To Function Effective Newspaper Reading Groups
Every year, I offering a distributed systems reading grouping seminar, where nosotros verbalise over recent interesting enquiry papers. (Here is the listing of papers nosotros covered this Spring.)
Reading grouping seminars are a lot of fun when everything clicks. But they tin easily plow into soul-draining irksome meetings when a duad of things acquire wrong. Here are roughly mutual bad coming together patterns: (1) the presenter goes on in addition to on amongst a dry out presentation, (2) without a mutual background, the participants bombard the presenter amongst a lot of questions only to acquire the context of the operate in addition to a lot of fourth dimension is wasted only to acquire started on the paper, (3) the audience drifts away (some autumn into their laptop screens, roughly start to fiddle amongst their phones), in addition to (4) inwards the give-and-take stage an awkward quiet sets inwards in addition to crickets chirp.
I accept been trying to tinker amongst the format of my reading grouping meetings to avoid those problems in addition to improve the odds that everything clicks together. And over fourth dimension I accept been learning from lawsuit in addition to fault what industrial plant in addition to what doesn't. Based on what I learned, hither is the most recent format I propose.
There are iii components to a successful reading grouping meeting: the participants, the presenter, in addition to the give-and-take process.
Cover alone 1 newspaper per meeting. Trying to encompass ii papers inwards i coming together does non work. It is likewise much operate to inquire the participants to read ii papers. Also ii papers per coming together dilutes the focus in addition to intensity.
Utilize the conference presentation video, if applicable. If the newspaper has a conference presentation video that actually helps. Watching that twenty infinitesimal pitch well-nigh the newspaper makes it much easier to read the newspaper than attempting a mutual frigidness reading of the paper. The OSDI in addition to SOSP conferences brand all the newspaper presentation videos openly available, which accept been of dandy assistance for our seminar group.
Solicit questions from the participants earlier the meeting. In lodge to acquire the participants to start thinking critically well-nigh the paper, I inquire them to write their questions inwards Piazza 1-2 days earlier the newspaper presentation. These questions also assistance the presenter to focus the presentation in addition to acquire prepared for the discussion.
Ask the presenter to submit a 2-3 page review of the paper. Preparing a powerpoint presentation alone creates a superficial understanding, or fifty-fifty a faux feel of safety that the presenter understands (and tin communicate) the paper. In lodge for the presenter to empathise the newspaper improve at a deeper conceptual level, I inquire the presenter to write a 2-3 page review of the paper.
The presenter prints the copies of his review in addition to brings this to the coming together for review earlier his presentation. All the participants review the hardcopy of the review-report inwards the kickoff fifteen minutes of the meeting. So inwards the kickoff fifteen minutes, it is all silence. The presenter is at the podium, getting adjusted, spell nosotros review his report. I got this thought from How I read a enquiry paper
How to acquaint your work
Tell me well-nigh your thought process, non only your results
How to write your enquiry paper
How I write
Good Prose in addition to How to write a lot
Advice to graduate students
Reading grouping seminars are a lot of fun when everything clicks. But they tin easily plow into soul-draining irksome meetings when a duad of things acquire wrong. Here are roughly mutual bad coming together patterns: (1) the presenter goes on in addition to on amongst a dry out presentation, (2) without a mutual background, the participants bombard the presenter amongst a lot of questions only to acquire the context of the operate in addition to a lot of fourth dimension is wasted only to acquire started on the paper, (3) the audience drifts away (some autumn into their laptop screens, roughly start to fiddle amongst their phones), in addition to (4) inwards the give-and-take stage an awkward quiet sets inwards in addition to crickets chirp.
I accept been trying to tinker amongst the format of my reading grouping meetings to avoid those problems in addition to improve the odds that everything clicks together. And over fourth dimension I accept been learning from lawsuit in addition to fault what industrial plant in addition to what doesn't. Based on what I learned, hither is the most recent format I propose.
There are iii components to a successful reading grouping meeting: the participants, the presenter, in addition to the give-and-take process.
1. The participants should come upward prepared.
Here are the tricks I flora to live on most effective for ensuring that the participants come upward to the grouping coming together having read the newspaper in addition to primed for fruitful discussion.Cover alone 1 newspaper per meeting. Trying to encompass ii papers inwards i coming together does non work. It is likewise much operate to inquire the participants to read ii papers. Also ii papers per coming together dilutes the focus in addition to intensity.
Utilize the conference presentation video, if applicable. If the newspaper has a conference presentation video that actually helps. Watching that twenty infinitesimal pitch well-nigh the newspaper makes it much easier to read the newspaper than attempting a mutual frigidness reading of the paper. The OSDI in addition to SOSP conferences brand all the newspaper presentation videos openly available, which accept been of dandy assistance for our seminar group.
Solicit questions from the participants earlier the meeting. In lodge to acquire the participants to start thinking critically well-nigh the paper, I inquire them to write their questions inwards Piazza 1-2 days earlier the newspaper presentation. These questions also assistance the presenter to focus the presentation in addition to acquire prepared for the discussion.
2. The presenter should come upward prepared.
Believe it or not, the presenter may come upward to the coming together amongst a superficial agreement of the paper. This makes things actually awkward. In lodge to ensure that the presenter comes gear upward amongst a deep agreement of the paper, these are what nosotros adopted.Ask the presenter to submit a 2-3 page review of the paper. Preparing a powerpoint presentation alone creates a superficial understanding, or fifty-fifty a faux feel of safety that the presenter understands (and tin communicate) the paper. In lodge for the presenter to empathise the newspaper improve at a deeper conceptual level, I inquire the presenter to write a 2-3 page review of the paper.
The presenter prints the copies of his review in addition to brings this to the coming together for review earlier his presentation. All the participants review the hardcopy of the review-report inwards the kickoff fifteen minutes of the meeting. So inwards the kickoff fifteen minutes, it is all silence. The presenter is at the podium, getting adjusted, spell nosotros review his report. I got this thought from How I read a enquiry paper
How to acquaint your work
Tell me well-nigh your thought process, non only your results
How to write your enquiry paper
How I write
Good Prose in addition to How to write a lot
Advice to graduate students
0 Response to "How To Function Effective Newspaper Reading Groups"
Post a Comment